Non-World Series Plays: Stunning Top 10 Missed Moments
When we think of baseball’s defining moments, the World Series often steals the spotlight. However, the thrill and heartbreak of the sport extend far beyond that iconic Fall Classic. Non-World Series plays frequently deliver some of the most jaw-dropping, unforgettable moments that fans and analysts alike debate for years. These plays, occurring in the regular season, playoffs, or even obscure games, highlight both the brilliance of players and the cruel sting of missed opportunities. Let’s dive into ten of the most stunning missed moments in baseball history that happened outside the World Series, shaking the game’s narrative and leaving fans breathless.
1. The Mays Catch That Almost Wasn’t: Willie Mays’ Missed Catch, 1953
Long before “The Catch” immortalized Willie Mays in the 1954 World Series, there was a lesser-known near-miss in 1953. Playing in a regular-season outfield battle, Mays almost failed to snag a routine fly ball that fell mere inches beyond his glove. Had it dropped, it could have cost his team the division lead. This close call reminded everyone how even legends flirt with failure and how moments off the World Series stage have career-defining tension.
2. Cal Ripken Jr.’s Almost Record-Breaking Error Streak
Cal Ripken Jr. is celebrated for his ironman streak and steadfast defense, but what is less recalled is how he nearly broke the error record for shortstops early in his career. During the 1980s, Ripken had an alarming drought of defensive mishaps that almost overshadowed his hitting prowess. These mistakes, occurring in regular-season gameplay, ignited debates about whether durable players sometimes sacrifice defensive precision for longevity, a controversy rarely discussed during the World Series narrative.
3. The Pine Tar Incident: George Brett’s Furious Outburst
One of the most talked-about moments in MLB history, the Pine Tar Incident did not happen in the World Series, but it rocked the sport like few others. In 1983, George Brett’s apparent home run was nullified because of excessive pine tar on his bat, leading to one of the most dramatic batter’s outbursts ever caught on camera. This incident raises questions about rules enforcement and whether the letter of the law should trump the spirit of the game—a controversy that overshadows many postseason glories.
4. The Bartman Incident: Miami Marlins Fans’ Notorious Error
Though more tragic for the Chicago Cubs during the 2003 National League Championship Series, the infamous Steve Bartman play was not a World Series event. This fan interference overshadowed the Cubs’ playoff chances and sparked widespread debate about fan responsibility and fairness. The event remains a cautionary tale of how a single non-World Series moment can define legacies and fan culture in baseball.
5. Ichiro Suzuki’s Almost Inside-the-Park Home Run
Known for his remarkable speed and hitting, Ichiro Suzuki came within inches of an inside-the-park home run during a regular-season game in 2005. His hit glanced off an outfielder’s glove and raced around the bases, but a desperate last-second tag at home plate narrowly prevented the feat. This near-miss highlights how spectacular baseball can be outside the postseason and the thin margin between historic feats and heartbreak.